September 23, 2020

Why private credit appeals to ESG investors

Investors wanting to meet environmental, social and governance criteria are looking closely at private credit but are also wanting to see more rigorous reporting and measurement.

This article originally appeared in Private Debt Investor in the September 2020 issue. By Sam Tillinghast, President, U.S. Private Credit, SLC Management and Liz Thorne, Senior Director, Private Fixed Income, SLC Management

In recent years, environmental social and governance investments have grown in popularity among institutional investors and high-net worth individuals. Demand has not faltered in the market downturn, as some thought it would. But with appetite for ESG growing, investors are faced with a new problem – finding enough good quality, high-yielding ESG investments.

Investment-grade private credit is becoming more popular among institutional investors as a result. The inherent nature of many investment grade private credit deals – in which individual projects or initiatives are financed – provides a clear picture of how the funds will be used. Compared to public markets, investors can tailor their portfolios to more tangible and measurable outcomes that meet their ESG goals.

At the same time, we are seeing a larger number of deals in the private markets that meet ESG criteria due to the growth in renewable energy, infrastructure and sustainability projects. The building stock in North America is ripe for energy efficiency and resiliency upgrades. Contracts for sustainable initiatives can be monetized, providing corporates, non-profits and government entities with long-term financing and providing investors with sustainable, high-quality investments. Many of these deals are investment-grade credit quality. This means they typically have durations that range from five to 30 years, often include collateral and financial covenants and are available across the rating spectrum.

But although we are seeing growth in the supply and demand for investment-grade private credit deals that fulfil ESG criteria, the sector still lags behind public markets on reporting and measuring ESG. Investors are keen to see more transparency on these deals, as information is in some respects harder to come by than in the public markets.

Greater specificity

There are some substantial advantages to investing in private credit markets when it comes to ESG. The main benefit is the specificity that an institutional investor can achieve in its portfolio. As divestment from certain companies and sectors becomes more mainstream, boards want to see more evidence for the impact of ESG investing and greater specificity in portfolios.  

Investors in investment-grade private credit are able to direct investments toward a specific use that provides environmental and/or social benefits, or at credits with revenue models tied to sustainable trends. This enables private credit investors to gain more precision around their ESG investments than they can in the public markets.

For that reason, investment-grade private credit is often an attractive funding vehicle for infrastructure projects. Investors can measure the impact of an investment in terms of factors such as amount of carbon offset and the populations who benefit. At the same time, operators are able to tailor deals to meet the needs of individual projects, which are often complex in nature.

Many of these investments fund projects that are natural fits for ESG-focused investors, such as renewable energy generation, hospitals and social services facilities. These transactions can directly be linked to projects that will help to prevent climate change and mitigate its impacts for vulnerable populations.

Not all ESG infrastructure projects are new build, though. We have also seen a lot of interest in energy savings performance contracts. These contracts support projects that improve the sustainability of existing government buildings and provide measurable environmental benefits that can be reported to investors. In the public and private sectors there will be increasing demand for buildings that are healthy both for the environment and the people who work in them. Many of these retrofit projects will be well suited for the investment-grade private market.

Attractive credit quality

In addition, from a credit quality and performance standpoint, ESG factors can also carry greater weight within the investment-grade private credit market. First, in analyzing investment-grade private credit deals, investors are often thinking about these investments over a longer time horizon than traditional bond investors. This presents a longer period for ESG factors to play out within an investment thesis.

Second, despite an active secondaries market, investors within the asset class are less able to move in and out of private deals on a frequent basis as their ESG views change. This means greater research is often required up front to ensure the deal accurately meets the goals of the investor.

The current market is providing an attractive entry point for investors looking to add investment-grade private credit to their portfolios. As well as the inherent ESG benefits discussed, investors can expect to pick up additional yield versus similar rated/duration public bonds, while experiencing lower downgrades and losses. This gives investors the freedom to add a very targeted ESG allocation without sacrificing portfolio yield to do so.

Moving toward transparency

As in most markets, the demand for ESG investments is a newer phenomenon. Even within private credit markets, this can sometimes lead to inconsistency and a lack of transparency across managers and issuers. Unlike public markets which, have numerous ESG indices and ratings, private markets are evaluated on a project-by-project basis. That means an investor has to do a lot of due diligence to establish whether or not an investment meets its ESG criteria.

To provide greater transparency to investors on material ESG factors, asset managers in the private credit space need to make their ESG assessment in bottom-up credit analyses more explicit. The advantage that private markets have over public markets, however, is that they have more access to the companies and underlying data to inform those opinions. There are multiple methods to evaluate the ESG factors of a particular company or credit issue.   

First, in a due diligence process, it is important to assess ESG at an individual issue level rather than only at an underlying credit level. This reflects the fact that each deal from the same issuer can be tied to a very different project. For example, some companies may be earlier in their  transition to cleaner energy, but an investor might still fund a project specifically tied to clean energy transition.

Second, managers can also use an expert network of former regulators, suppliers, employees and competitors to delve into the “S” and “G” factors. It is important to validate ESG data using knowledgeable sources in addition to management reporting. The Covid crisis has highlighted the importance of this risk analysis to credit underwriting. For instance, when evaluating governance impacts, companies with strong leadership were better prepared for catastrophic disruptions, and those with systems and technology that could be adapted quickly for remote work fared better.

Third, if any specific questions or concerns arise during the due diligence process or after the investment is made, a private credit investor can raise this with the management team. Conversations about a company’s forward-looking plans are not limited to scheduled investor updates, which allows for more openness. This is particularly helpful for companies that are transitioning towards greater sustainability or that have complex operating structures, as private debt markets can provide the borrower with more flexibility, while offering greater access to information for the investor. 

Although, private credits have typically lagged public credits on measuring and reporting, the ability to directly tie an individual deal to a specific project and the attached ESG benefits offers the potential for greater substance and transparency in ESG reporting. As ESG becomes more commonplace in conversations between institutional investors and private credit managers, we expect to see a further increase in the metrics that will enable the impact of these investments to be properly evaluated.

About SLC Management

SLC Management is the brand name for the institutional asset management business of Sun Life Financial Inc. (“Sun Life”) under which Sun Life Capital Management (U.S.) LLC in the United States, and Sun Life Capital Management (Canada) Inc. in Canada operate.

Sun Life Capital Management (Canada) Inc. is a Canadian registered portfolio manager, investment fund manager, exempt market dealer and in Ontario, a commodity trading manager. Sun Life Capital Management (U.S.) LLC is registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission as an investment adviser and is also a Commodity Trading Advisor and Commodity Pool Operator registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission under the Commodity Exchange Act and Members of the National Futures Association.

BentallGreenOak, InfraRed Capital Partners (InfraRed) and Crescent Capital Group (Crescent), and Advisors Asset Management are also part of SLC Management.

BentallGreenOak is a global real estate investment management advisor and a provider of real estate services. In the U.S., real estate mandates are offered by BentallGreenOak (U.S.) Limited Partnership, who is registered with the SEC as an investment adviser, or Sun Life Institutional Distributors (U.S.) LLC, an SEC registered broker-dealer and a member of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (“FINRA”) . In Canada, real estate mandates are offered by BentallGreenOak (Canada) Limited Partnership, BGO Capital (Canada) Inc. or Sun Life Capital Management (Canada) Inc. BGO Capital (Canada) Inc. is a Canadian registered portfolio manager and exempt market dealer and is registered as an investment fund manager in British Columbia, Ontario and Quebec.

InfraRed Capital Partners is an international investment manager focused on infrastructure. Operating worldwide, InfraRed manages equity capital in multiple private and listed funds, primarily for institutional investors across the globe. InfraRed Capital Partners Ltd. is authorized and regulated in the UK by the Financial Conduct Authority.

Crescent Capital Group is a global alternative credit investment asset manager registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission as an investment adviser. Crescent provides private credit financing (including senior, unitranche and junior debt) to middle-market companies in the U.S. and Europe, and invests in high-yield bonds and broadly syndicated loans.

Securities will only be offered and sold in compliance with applicable securities laws.

AAM is an independent U.S. retail distribution firm that provides a range of solutions and products to financial advisors at wirehouses, registered investment advisors and independent broker-dealers.

Website content

The content of this website is intended for institutional investors only. It is not for retail use or distribution to individual investors. All investments involve risk including the possible loss of capital. All asset classes have associated risks. Certain asset classes are speculative, can include a high degree of risk and are suitable only for long-term investment. Further information available upon request. This website is for informational and educational purposes only. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.

The information contained in this website is not intended to provide specific financial, tax, investment, insurance, legal or accounting advice and should not be relied upon and does not constitute a specific offer to buy and/or sell securities, insurance or investment services. Investors should consult with their professional advisors before acting upon any information contained on this website. The assets under management (AUM) represent the combined AUM of Sun Life Capital Management (Canada) Inc., Sun Life Capital Management (U.S) LLC, BentallGreenOak, Crescent Capital Group, InfraRed Capital Partners, and Advisors Asset Management.

AUM as of March 31, 2025. Total firm AUM includes approximately $11B in cash, other, unfunded commitments, and Advisors Asset Management equity. Total firm AUM excludes $16 billion in assets under administration by AAM.

Currency conversion rate: USD $1.00 CAD $1.4387 as of March 31, 2025.

UK Tax Strategy - InfraRed (UK) Holdco 2020 Limited

InfraRed (UK) Holdco 2020 Ltd is the UK holding company of InfraRed Partners LLP and a subsidiary of Sun Life (U.S.) Holdco 2020 Inc, which has its headquarters in the U.S. The company was incorporated to purchase InfraRed Partners LLP and acts solely as a passive holding company. The Tax Strategy for the InfraRed Holdco Group sets out our approach to the management of InfraRed Holdco Group UK tax affairs in supporting business activities in the UK. 

This UK tax strategy is published in accordance with the requirements set out in Schedule 19 of Finance Act 2016. The strategy, which has been approved by the Board of Directors of InfraRed (UK) Holdco 2020 Ltd, is effective for the period ending 31 December 2024. It applies to InfraRed (UK) Holdco 2020 Ltd and its dormant subsidiary Sun Life (UK) Designated Member Ltd, referred to as the “InfraRed Holdco Group”. InfraRed Holdco Group.